Want to bring the Stanley Cup back to Canada? Cut taxes, says new report

OTTAWA — It’s been 33 years since a Canadian team last hoisted the NHL’s Stanley Cup, a drought that looks likely to continue with the Montreal Canadiens falling to a 3-1 deficit in the Eastern Conference finals.

Gabriel Giguère, an analyst with the Montreal Economic Institute (MEI) and die-hard Habs fan, says that part of what’s plaguing Canadian hockey markets is high taxes.

“If Quebec wants to have a winning hockey team, they should lower taxes to help the Montreal Canadiens attract the best players,” says Giguère. “That’s pretty clear from the numbers.”

Giguère is one of the authors of a new MEI study on tax competitiveness and team performance across the NHL’s 32 markets.

The study finds that NHL’s so-called Sunbelt advantage— referring to the recent success of teams located in low-tax jurisdictions across the southern United States — isn’t an aberration. It reflects a consistent statistical relationship between taxation and performance.

The study reports that, between 1980 and 2017, every one per cent increase in the local tax rate reduced an NHL team’s win rate by 1.55 to 1.57 percentage points. This was about 2.5 times higher than average across all major North American sports leagues.

Giguère says the mixture of short peak windows for individual athletes and the high risk of injury in hockey create especially strong incentives for NHLers to maximize their net incomes.

“There’s a very high level of uncertainty for every player in the NHL, between declining performance and the potential for getting hurt that comes with every shift,” says Giguère.

Across the league, there’s a more than 15 per cent differential between the lowest taxed markets, all in the U.S., and the most heavily taxed ones, all in Canada.

Montreal is the league’s most taxed market, with an effective tax rate of 48.57 per cent.

Giguère says the Montreal Canadiens, which have the NHL’s youngest roster with an average age of 26.2, are getting a temporary boost from an explosive young core. He adds they’ll have trouble keeping this group together as players age into free agency.

Under the current league rules, players who are either older than 27, have completed seven accrued NHL seasons or have expired contracts, may qualify as unrestricted free agents, meaning they can offer their services to the highest bidder.

Four of the last six Stanley Cups have been won by teams from Florida, a state with no personal income tax.

This year, another low-tax jurisdiction team, Nevada’s Vegas Golden Knights, will be heading to its third Stanley Cup finals in nine years, led by ex-Toronto Maple Leafs sniper Mitch Marner.

Marner dodged an approximate $3.75-million annual tax bill by leaving Toronto.