Canada's scary debt problem: Federal, provincial debt to exceed $2.4 trillion this year, report finds

As prices for just about everything skyrocket and an untold number of Canadians are going deeper into debt trying to keep up, the Fraser Institute’s latest study is a reminder that Canada and the provinces have been hurdling their own roads of indebtedness since the 2008 recession.

In its latest research bulletin on the growing debt burden for Canadians, the public policy organization found that the combined federal and provincial net debt, adjusted for inflation, has nearly doubled from $1.24 trillion in 2007-08 to a projected $2.44 trillion this fiscal year, a growth of 97.7 per cent.

In 2024, the Fraser Institute forecast it to reach $2.2 trillion and last year it was $2.3 trillion.

Most of the $1.2 trillion over the 18-year study period was accrued by Ottawa, projected to have increased $712.7 billion (93.7 per cent) over that time, particularly during its response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

In fact, Jake Fuss, the author and the institute’s director of fiscal studies, found that from 2019-20 until this fiscal year, both levels of government are projected to have collectively accumulated $603.7 billion in net debt, an increase of 32.8 per cent.

With the pandemic well in the rearview, Fuss said now is the time for a plan to address government debt.

“A long-term plan to return to balanced budgets is necessary if Canadian governments are going to begin the difficult task of stemming debt accumulation and eventually reducing the debt burden,” he wrote.

The bulletin notes that Ottawa and the provinces “have decisively broken from the era of fiscal prudence” exhibited from the mid-1990s to the late aughts and returned to an era similar to the 1970s to the 1990s, when accumulating debt and increasing deficits “became the norm.”

In comparison, in the 12 years before the study period, federal net debt was reduced by $364.5 billion.

“Put differently, in the past 18 years, the federal government has accumulated nearly double the amount of debt that it repaid in the mid-1990s to late-2000s,” Fuss explained.

At the provincial level, over the last 15 years, Alberta went from being the only province with a net financial asset position — meaning its assets were greater than its liabilities — to join the list of provinces with “a fast-growing debt burden” by adding $91.3 billion in net debt.

B.C. leads that category with a shocking 200 per cent debt increase to $70.3 billion over the 18 years, followed by Manitoba (144.7 per cent to $22.5 billion), Saskatchewan (108.9 per cent to $9.4 billion), and Ontario (94.9 per cent), the province with the highest debt at $459.4 billion. Net debt in Quebec and three of the four Atlantic Canadian provinces, save for P.E.I., has increased 35 per cent or less.

The annual study also explored the debt as a share of the Canadian economy, the GDP, and found that “combined net debt now equals a projected 75.4 per cent.” Federal debt accounts for the lion’s share at 45.4 per cent to the province’s 29.9 per cent.